Rehoboth Beach's Favorite Scoop Since Day One

We Make Ice Cream Like It's the Last One You'll Ever Taste

Small-batch, hand-churned, and made fresh every morning right here on Wilmington Avenue. No shortcuts, no industrial freezers — just real cream, real fruit, and real care in every scoop.

See Today's Flavors Find Us on the Beach

50+

Flavors Rotated Weekly

100%

Small-Batch Made

Daily

Fresh Churned

A generous scoop of vanilla bean ice cream in a waffle cone, with soft summer light

Open Now

Until 10 PM

What's in the Tank

Today's Flavor Lineup

We churn fresh every morning, so what's available depends on the weather, the season, and whatever sounds delicious that day. Here's what's calling your name right now:

Creamy vanilla bean ice cream in a glass dish

Classic

Madagascar Vanilla

Real vanilla beans, split and scraped. Rich, warm, and the kind of vanilla that makes you close your eyes.

Bright red strawberry ice cream with fresh berries on top

Seasonal

Jersey Strawberry

Fresh Jersey strawberries, crushed into a sweet-tart base. Picked at peak and churned the same day.

Dark chocolate ice cream with a glossy swirl

Rich

Dark Chocolate Fudge

70% cocoa, double-churned for density. Fudgy, intense, and somehow still scoopable.

Tropical

Mango Passion

Alphonso mangoes and a whisper of passion fruit. Bright, sunny, and completely dairy-free.

Mint chocolate chip ice cream with visible chocolate chips

Fan Favorite

Garden Mint Chip

Fresh mint from the garden, steeped into cream, with hand-chopped dark chocolate ribbons.

Coffee ice cream with a smooth brown swirl

Adults Only

Cold Brew Coffee

Rehoboth Beach coffee, steeped overnight in our base. For the 3 PM slump and the 9 PM wind-down.

Flavors change daily — stop by or give us a call to check what's cold today.

A chef scooping fresh ice cream in a bright kitchen

A close-up of ice cream being scooped into a cone

Our Story

We Started With a Pot, a Freezer, and a Lot of Taste-Testing

Starkey's wasn't born in a boardroom. It started the way the best things do — with someone who couldn't find good ice cream anywhere nearby, so they decided to make it themselves.

Every batch is hand-churned in small quantities right here in Rehoboth Beach. We source local cream, whole milk from nearby farms, and fruit from growers who actually know our name. If a flavor doesn't make us excited, it doesn't make the menu.

We're not a chain. We're not outsourcing to a factory. When you walk into Starkey's, the person scooping your cone probably made that batch this morning. That's the difference.

Local Cream

Fresh Fruit

Small Batches

Find Us

Come Say Hi

We're right on Wilmington Avenue, just a short walk from the boardwalk. Pull up, grab a scoop, and stay a while.

Get in Touch

Location

13 S Wilmington Avenue
Rehoboth Beach, DE 19971

Phone

(484) 557-7269

Call ahead to check flavor availability

Hours

Mon – Thu: 11 AM – 9 PM

Fri – Sat: 11 AM – 10 PM

Sunday: 12 PM – 9 PM

Summer hours may vary — follow us for updates